Cleveland Cavaliers: Complete 2017 offseason grades
Traded Irving for Thomas
The tension and drama of the Cleveland Cavaliers was stretched to the limit when it was revealed that All-Star point guard Kyrie Irving was requesting to be traded to another team. Memories of Shaq and Kobe, predictions about Klay Thompson following the same path, and questions about where Kyrie would end up dominated NBA discussions during a period that is generally quiet.
When the Cavaliers did pull the trigger on a deal, it was with a surprising partner — the Boston Celtics. Boston is easily the biggest threat to the Cavaliers in the East, Kyrie Irving or no, and as such it was shocking to see the Cavaliers dealing with them, especially on such a scale.
But trade they did, sending Kyrie Irving to the Celtics in exchange for All-NBA guard Isaiah Thomas, wing Jae Crowder, center Ante Zizic and the Brooklyn Nets’ 2018 unprotected pick. However, when the Cavs did their medical testing on Thomas they saw something they didn’t like, and returned to Boston to demand a higher ransom. In the end Boston didn’t flinch, merely blinked, and tossed in a future second round pick.
From the Cavaliers perspective, a healthy Thomas replicates 80-90 percent of Irving’s production on both ends of the court. Slot him in, add the defensive ace Crowder, and the center Zizic, and suddenly the Cavaliers have rotation players that can challenge the Warriors’ versatility. The Brooklyn pick is an unexpectedly sweet prize.
For the Cavaliers they set themselves up for now and in the future. This trade represents a clean walkaway with the best pieces in the deal.
Grade: A